There’s nothing quite like a perfectly toasted English muffin – crispy on the outside, warm and fluffy on the inside, with all those glorious “nooks and crannies” ready to soak up butter, jam, or your favorite breakfast toppings. But getting that ideal toast can be a challenge if you don’t have the right equipment. Many standard toasters just don’t cut it, often leaving your muffin unevenly browned or, worse, stuck in the slots!
If you’re on the hunt for the best toaster for English muffins, you’ve come to the right place. We’ve scoured the market to bring you a selection of top-notch toasters designed to handle English muffins with ease, ensuring an even, golden brown finish every time. And because a great toaster deserves a great muffin, we’ve also included some of the most beloved English muffin brands that will make your breakfast truly unforgettable. Let’s dive in and find your perfect morning companion!
Top Toasters for English Muffin Perfection
These toasters are designed with features that make them ideal for English muffins, ensuring you get that perfect crunch and soft interior every single time.
Elite Gourmet ECT1027G Cool-Touch 2 Slice Toaster
Looking for a sleek, compact toaster that can handle your English muffins without breaking a sweat? The Elite Gourmet ECT1027G is a fantastic choice. Its cool-touch design means you won’t accidentally burn your fingers, and the extra-wide slots are specifically designed to accommodate bagels, waffles, and, of course, your favorite English muffins. Plus, with its self-centering guides, you can trust that every slice will be toasted to an even, golden brown perfection.
- Key Features:
- COOL-TOUCH COMPACT STYLE: Modern gunmetal gray finish, safe to touch during operation.
- NOT JUST FOR TOAST: Extra-wide 1.25″ slots perfect for English muffins, bagels, and thick breads.
- 6 ADJUSTABLE TOASTING SHADES: Customize browning from light to dark.
- SELF-CENTERING: Ensures even heat distribution for consistent results.
- CONVENIENT CANCEL BUTTON: Interrupts toasting cycle instantly.
- Pros:
- Stylish and compact design fits well in any kitchen.
- Wide slots are excellent for English muffins and thicker items.
- Cool-touch exterior adds safety.
- Consistent toasting thanks to self-centering guides.
- Cons:
- Only two slots, might be slow for larger families.
- Some users found the browning levels could be a bit inconsistent initially.
- User Impressions: Customers frequently praise this toaster for its reliable performance and attractive design. Many highlight its ability to evenly toast thicker items like English muffins and bagels, appreciating the cool-touch feature for added peace of mind. It’s often recommended for smaller kitchens or individuals who toast a variety of breads.
- See it on Amazon here
Nostalgia New and Improved Wide 2-Slice Toaster
If you appreciate a touch of retro charm mixed with modern functionality, the Nostalgia Wide 2-Slice Toaster is a delightful contender. This toaster boasts extra-wide slots, making it a dream for English muffin enthusiasts who dread trying to squeeze their beloved breakfast into narrow openings. With intuitive lighted controls and multiple browning levels, you’re in full command of your toast’s crispiness.
- Key Features:
- EXTRA-WIDE TOASTER: 2 large slots ideal for bagels, thick bread slices, and English muffins.
- LIGHTED CONTROLS: Easy-to-see buttons for bagel, defrost, and cancel options.
- PERFECTLY TOASTED: 5 browning levels for customized crispiness.
- CORD STORAGE: Tidy storage in the bottom of the unit.
- EASY CLEAN UP: Removable crumb tray for quick maintenance.
- Pros:
- Extra-wide slots are perfect for English muffins and thicker items.
- Simple, intuitive controls.
- Attractive retro aesthetic.
- Easy to clean with a slide-out crumb tray.
- Cons:
- Some users wish for more than 5 browning levels for finer control.
- The exterior can get warm during operation.
- User Impressions: Reviewers love the Nostalgia toaster for its ability to toast bagels and English muffins without issue, often commenting on its charming design. Many find the controls straightforward and appreciate the ease of cleaning. It’s often cited as a reliable and aesthetically pleasing kitchen appliance.
- See it on Amazon here
BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster, Extra Wide Slots
When you need to feed more than just yourself or simply want to speed up your morning routine, the BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster is a powerhouse. Its extra-wide slots are a godsend for busy mornings, effortlessly accommodating English muffins, thick slices of artisanal bread, and bagels. The push-button bagel function ensures a perfect golden brown on one side and warm on the other, while the seven shade settings let everyone in the family have their toast just the way they like it. This truly is one of the best toaster for English muffins for families.
- Key Features:
- EXTRA-WIDE TOASTING SLOTS: Accommodates bagels, thick breads, and English muffins.
- BAGEL FUNCTION: Crisps one side and warms the other – ideal for English muffins.
- EXTRA LIFT: Lever lifts toast higher for safe and easy retrieval.
- DROP-DOWN CRUMB TRAY: Keeps counters clean and prevents burnt crumb smells.
- SHADE SELECTOR: 7 browning levels from light to dark.
- Pros:
- Four slots are great for families or multiple users.
- Bagel function is excellent for custom toasting.
- Extra lift feature prevents burnt fingers.
- Easy-to-clean crumb tray.
- Cons:
- Can be larger on the countertop due to 4-slice capacity.
- Some users noted variable browning across different slots occasionally.
- User Impressions: This Black+Decker toaster is a hit with families and those who regularly toast multiple items. Customers frequently highlight its generous slot size for English muffins and bagels, and the extra lift feature is a definite favorite. The multiple shade settings also receive praise for accommodating various preferences.
- See it on Amazon here
Pair Your Perfect Toaster with These Delicious English Muffins
A great toaster is only half the equation! To get the ultimate English muffin experience, you need high-quality muffins with those classic “nooks and crannies.” Here are some top picks that toast up beautifully.
365 Everyday Value, White English Muffins, 15 oz, 6 CT
For those who prioritize wholesome ingredients and a classic taste, the 365 Everyday Value White English Muffins from Whole Foods Market are an excellent choice. These muffins are crafted to be fresh, never frozen, ensuring a delightful texture right out of the package. They’re also vegan and low in sodium, making them a conscious choice for many breakfast tables. When popped into one of the best toaster for English muffins, these will achieve a perfect golden brown.
- Key Features:
- Brought to you by Whole Foods Market: Ensures quality and specific sourcing standards.
- Fresh, never frozen: Provides optimal texture and taste.
- Vegan: Suitable for plant-based diets.
- Low sodium: A healthier option for daily consumption.
- Pros:
- Great taste and texture, especially when fresh.
- Healthier attributes like vegan and low sodium.
- Reliable quality from a trusted brand.
- Cons:
- Availability might be limited to Whole Foods Market or Amazon Fresh.
- Being fresh, they have a shorter shelf life than frozen options.
- User Impressions: Shoppers consistently praise the fresh taste and soft interior of these English muffins. Many vegans appreciate having a readily available option. They’re often described as having a good balance of crispiness when toasted and a soft, chewy interior, making them a breakfast staple.
- See it on Amazon here
Thomas’ Original English Muffins, 6 Count, 13 Oz Package
When you think of English muffins, Thomas’ is often the first name that comes to mind, and for good reason! Their Original English Muffins are legendary for their distinctive “Nooks & Crannies” texture, which is absolutely perfect for holding butter, jam, or any other topping. These low-fat muffins are a versatile base for anything from a simple toast to a hearty breakfast sandwich or even a mini pizza!
- Key Features:
- One 13 oz package of 6 Thomas’ Original English Muffins.
- Low fat English Muffins with the Nooks & Crannies texture for a delicious breakfast classic.
- Versatile for various toppings and breakfast creations.
- Pros:
- Iconic Nooks & Crannies absorb toppings beautifully.
- Consistently great taste and texture.
- Low fat, making them a guilt-free pleasure.
- Widely available in most grocery stores.
- Cons:
- Contains high fructose corn syrup, which some consumers avoid.
- Packaging sometimes results in slightly crushed muffins.
- User Impressions: These are an undisputed fan favorite. Customers rave about the classic taste and, of course, those famous Nooks & Crannies. They’re celebrated for their versatility and how well they toast up to a golden crispness, making them ideal for everything from breakfast spreads to egg sandwiches.
- See it on Amazon here
Thomas’ Light Multi Grain English Muffins, 6 Count, 12 Oz Package
For those looking for a healthier twist on the classic, Thomas’ Light Multi Grain English Muffins offer the same beloved “Nooks & Crannies” texture with added fiber and fewer calories. These muffins are designed for convenience, easily splitting without a knife to preserve their unique texture, making them perfect for on-the-go breakfasts or quick English muffin sandwiches. They bring that satisfying crunch and fluffy interior you expect, just with a little extra goodness.
- Key Features:
- One 12 oz package of 6 Thomas’ Light Multi Grain English Muffins.
- Low fat English Muffins with the trademark Nooks and Crannies texture.
- Easy to split without a knife for convenience and texture preservation.
- Each light English Muffin contains 8 g of fiber and 1/3 fewer calories than regular English Muffins.
- Pros:
- High in fiber and lower in calories than traditional muffins.
- Maintains the iconic Nooks & Crannies texture.
- Convenient to split and use.
- Great multi-grain flavor.
- Cons:
- Some prefer the taste of the original recipe.
- May be slightly less “fluffy” than the original due to multi-grain content.
- User Impressions: Many health-conscious customers appreciate the increased fiber and reduced calories without sacrificing the quintessential Thomas’ experience. They toast up well, achieving a satisfying crisp, and the multi-grain flavor is a welcome addition for those seeking a more robust taste. It’s a popular choice for daily breakfast.
- See it on Amazon here
Thomas’ Original English Muffins, 12 count, (6 ct each)
When six English muffins just aren’t enough, Thomas’ offers a convenient 12-count package of their famous Original English Muffins. This bulk option ensures you always have a fresh supply of those essential “Nooks & Crannies” for your daily breakfast or family brunches. Packed in a tray for freshness, these muffins are ready to be toasted to perfection, providing that same classic taste and texture that has made Thomas’ a household name for generations.
- Key Features:
- 12 count inside, English Muffins (2 packs of 6).
- Original English Muffins with the classic Nooks & Crannies.
- Packed in a tray for freshness and convenience.
- Pros:
- Great value and quantity for families or frequent users.
- Same beloved taste and texture of Thomas’ Original.
- Convenient packaging helps maintain freshness.
- Cons:
- Larger package means more to store if not consumed quickly.
- Still contains high fructose corn syrup like the 6-count original.
- User Impressions: This 12-count package is a go-to for many who want to stock up on their favorite English muffins. Customers love the consistent quality and the fact that they can enjoy the classic taste for longer. They perform wonderfully in a wide-slot toaster, achieving a delightful crispiness every time.
- See it on Amazon here
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Finding the right toaster and perfecting your English muffin toast can raise a few questions. Here are some common queries answered to help you achieve breakfast bliss!
Q1: What makes a toaster “good for English muffins”?
A1: The primary feature is extra-wide slots (usually 1.25 inches or more) to accommodate their thickness. Additionally, a bagel function (which toasts one side more intensely than the other) is great for achieving that perfect crisp exterior and soft interior. Self-centering guides also ensure even browning.
Q2: Should I split my English muffin with a knife or fork?
A2: Traditionally, English muffins are best split with a fork. Poking around the edge creates a rough, uneven surface that enhances those famous “nooks and crannies,” allowing them to get extra crispy and soak up more butter or jam. Using a knife can flatten these crucial textures.
Q3: How do I prevent English muffins from getting stuck in the toaster?
A3: Always use a toaster with extra-wide slots to begin with. If your muffin does get stuck, always unplug the toaster first before attempting to dislodge it with a non-metallic utensil (like a wooden or plastic spatula). Never use metal!
Q4: Can I toast frozen English muffins?
A4: Absolutely! Many modern toasters come with a defrost function specifically for this purpose. If yours doesn’t, simply set it to a lighter shade and run it for one cycle to thaw, then re-toast on a regular setting to achieve your desired crispness.
Q5: What’s the ideal browning setting for English muffins?
A5: This is largely a matter of personal preference! Most people prefer a medium-to-dark setting (around 4-6 on a typical toaster dial) to get a truly golden brown and crispy exterior while keeping the inside warm and soft. Experiment to find your perfect shade.
Q6: Are toaster ovens good for English muffins?
A6: Toaster ovens can certainly toast English muffins. They often provide more space, which is great for thicker items. However, they might take a bit longer than a traditional slot toaster, and achieving consistent, even browning across the muffin’s surface might require flipping. They are excellent for keeping multiple muffins warm, though!
Q7: How do I clean my toaster’s crumb tray?
A7: Most toasters have a removable crumb tray at the bottom. Simply slide it out, discard the accumulated crumbs, and wipe the tray clean with a damp cloth. Ensure it’s completely dry before reinserting. Regular cleaning prevents burnt odors and maintains hygiene.
We hope this guide helps you find the best toaster for English muffins and the perfect muffins to go with it, ensuring every morning starts with a perfectly crispy, fluffy bite! Happy toasting!
