Who doesn’t love a perfectly toasted bagel to kickstart their day? That satisfying golden crisp on the cut side, warm and chewy on the other – it’s a morning ritual many of us cherish. But let’s be honest, finding a toaster that truly handles bagels well can be a challenge. Too often, we end up with burnt edges, undercooked middles, or frustratingly stuck slices.
Fear not, bagel enthusiasts! We’ve scoured the market to bring you a curated list of the best toasters for bagels, designed to deliver that ideal breakfast experience every single time. We’re talking extra-wide slots, dedicated bagel functions, and intelligent browning settings that make all the difference. Say goodbye to toaster struggles and hello to bagel bliss!
What Makes a Toaster Great for Bagels?
Before diving into our top picks, let’s quickly touch on what features make a toaster truly bagel-friendly:
- Extra-Wide Slots: This is non-negotiable. Bagels are thick, so you need slots wide enough to accommodate them without squishing.
- Bagel Function: Many toasters offer a specific “bagel” setting. This often toasts the cut side more intensely while gently warming the crust, preventing over-browning.
- Even Browning: Nobody wants a half-toasted bagel. Look for toasters that promise consistent heat distribution.
- High-Lift Lever: Essential for safely retrieving smaller items like English muffins or the last bits of your bagel without burning your fingers.
- Removable Crumb Tray: A must-have for easy cleaning and keeping your countertop tidy.
Ready to find your perfect bagel companion? Let’s check out the top best toasters for bagels on the market!
Our Top Picks: The Best Toasters for Bagels
BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster, Extra Wide Slots, 7 Shade…
This BLACK+DECKER toaster is a fantastic choice for families or anyone who loves variety at breakfast. Its standout feature is the combination of truly extra-wide slots and a dedicated bagel function, ensuring your thickest bagels fit comfortably and toast precisely. With its classic design and straightforward controls, it’s built for reliability and ease of use, making your morning routine a breeze.
- Key Features:
- EXTRA-WIDE TOASTING SLOTS: Accommodates bagels, thick breads, and more.
- BAGEL FUNCTION: Perfect crisp on the cut side, with controls for frozen items and to end toasting.
- EXTRA LIFT: Lever safely lifts toast within reach.
- DROP-DOWN CRUMB TRAY: Easy cleaning to keep counters tidy.
- SHADE SELECTOR: Knob from 1-7 for customizable browning.
- Pros:
- Handles thick bagels and artisan bread with ease.
- Dedicated bagel setting for optimal toasting.
- Simple, intuitive controls.
- Easy crumb tray for quick cleanup.
- Cons:
- Some users might prefer a more modern aesthetic.
- No digital display for countdown.
- User Impressions: Customers often praise this toaster for its consistent performance with bagels and thick bread. They appreciate the simplicity and effectiveness of the bagel function, noting it’s a great value for a 4-slice model. Cleanup is frequently mentioned as a positive, thanks to the drop-down crumb tray.
- See it on Amazon here
Elite Gourmet ECT4123X Long Slot 4 Slice Toaster, Extra…
If you’re a fan of artisan loaves, long slices of sourdough, or simply want to fit two bagel halves in one slot, the Elite Gourmet ECT4123X is a game-changer. Its uniquely long and extra-wide slots are incredibly versatile, fitting specialty breads that traditional toasters can’t handle. Coupled with its ‘true bagel’ function, this toaster ensures a perfectly golden bagel inside, while keeping the outside warm and soft – pure perfection!
- Key Features:
- 2 EXTRA LARGE TOASTING SLOTS: 1.5” wide, 10” long & 5.1” deep to fit up to 4 extra thick slices.
- ONE TOUCH BUTTONS WITH TRUE BAGEL, DEFROST & REHEAT FUNCTIONS: Easy operation for various needs.
- 6 ADJUSTABLE TOASTING LEVELS: For the perfect browning shade.
- REHEAT WARMING FUNCTION: Warm previously toasted bread without over-toasting.
- CONVENIENT CANCEL/EJECT BUTTON: Stop the cycle anytime.
- Pros:
- Exceptional slot length for unique bread types.
- Dedicated ‘true bagel’ function for ideal bagel toasting.
- Multiple functions (defrost, reheat, cancel) enhance versatility.
- Adjustable browning for precise control.
- Cons:
- The long slot design might take up more counter space for some.
- Only 2 physical slots (but fits 4 standard slices/2 large bagels).
- User Impressions: Reviewers love the flexibility offered by the long slots, especially for Texas toast and bagels. The ‘true bagel’ function receives high marks for delivering consistent results, and many appreciate the straightforward one-touch controls. It’s often recommended for those who regularly toast larger or specialty breads.
- See it on Amazon here
Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster 4 Slice,…
The Mueller UltraToast doesn’t just look sleek in any modern kitchen; it’s also incredibly smart. Crafted with full stainless steel, this 4-slice toaster boasts extra-wide slots and intelligent heating technology for even browning. What truly sets it apart are the six browning settings with memory recall and an LED display, allowing you to save your favorite toast level and enjoy perfectly warmed bagels exactly how you like them, morning after morning.
- Key Features:
- Multifunctional Toaster: Cancel, Defrost, and Reheat functions with self-centering slot guides.
- Full Control: Six browning settings with memory recall and sleek touch buttons/LED display.
- Extra-Wide Slots: 1.6 inch wide slots for artisan bread, Texas toast, bagels, English muffins.
- Effortless Cleaning: Removable crumb tray and under-base cord storage.
- Superior Quality With Mueller: Premium components and responsive customer support.
- Pros:
- Stylish stainless steel design.
- Memory recall for browning settings is a fantastic convenience.
- LED display provides clear feedback.
- Extra-wide slots handle a variety of thick items.
- Easy to clean and store.
- Cons:
- Might be a higher price point than basic models.
- Touch buttons could be less tactile for some users.
- User Impressions: Customers consistently praise the Mueller UltraToast for its sophisticated appearance and reliable performance. The memory function is a big hit, as is the even toasting across all slots. Many consider it a worthy investment for its durability and ease of use, making it one of the top best toasters for bagels.
- See it on Amazon here
Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster, With 6 Browning Settings,…
Sometimes, simplicity and functionality are all you need, and the Amazon Basics 2-Slice Toaster delivers just that. It’s a no-frills, reliable option perfect for smaller households or individual bagel lovers. Despite its straightforward design, it doesn’t skimp on essential features, including extra-wide slots for bagels and a dedicated bagel setting to ensure your morning treat is toasted just right without breaking the bank.
- Key Features:
- 2-slice toaster: Perfect for 1 or 2 slices of bread at a time.
- 6 shade settings: Accommodate individual preferences.
- Extra-wide slots: For bagels and thicker slices (5-1/4 inches long by 1-1/4 inches wide).
- Bagel setting: Toasts just the cut side; Frozen setting, Cancel function.
- Extra-lift lever: For safely removing smaller pieces.
- Removable crumb tray: For easy cleaning.
- Pros:
- Excellent value for money.
- Compact size, ideal for small kitchens.
- Extra-wide slots and bagel function work well for thick items.
- Easy to use with illuminated buttons.
- Cord wrap for neat storage.
- Cons:
- Only 2 slices, so not ideal for larger families.
- Basic aesthetic compared to premium models.
- User Impressions: This toaster is highly rated for its affordability and effectiveness. Users are often surprised by how well it performs for the price, particularly for bagels and thicker breads. Its compact footprint is a plus for those with limited counter space, making it a popular choice for a basic yet capable bagel toaster.
- See it on Amazon here
Proctor Silex 4 Slice Toaster with Extra Wide Slots for…
The Proctor Silex 4 Slice Toaster is all about convenience and reliability, especially when you’re dealing with a busy breakfast rush. Its standout feature is the Toast Boost, which lifts smaller breads higher, making it super easy to grab English muffins or smaller bagel halves without a struggle. Combined with extra-wide slots and a shade selector, this toaster focuses on straightforward functionality, ensuring a hassle-free toasting experience for a variety of breads.
- Key Features:
- EFFORTLESSLY TOAST THICKER BREADS: Extra wide slots easily fit Texas toast and bagels.
- EASILY RETRIEVE SMALLER-SIZED BREADS: Toast Boost feature lifts smaller items higher.
- KEEP COUNTERTOPS CLEANER: Pullout crumb tray for easy cleaning.
- CUSTOMIZE YOUR TOAST SHADE: 7 toast shades with a cancel button.
- NEATLY STORES AWAY: Built-in cord wrap.
- AUTO SHUTOFF FOR PEACE OF MIND: Automatically shuts off if toast gets jammed.
- Pros:
- Toast Boost is very handy for small items.
- Extra-wide slots accommodate bagels and thick bread.
- Auto shutoff provides an important safety feature.
- Easy to clean with a pullout crumb tray.
- Good value for a 4-slice toaster.
- Cons:
- Lacks a dedicated “bagel” button (relies on extra-wide slots and shade).
- Design is utilitarian rather than sleek.
- User Impressions: Many users appreciate this toaster for its reliable performance and the convenient Toast Boost feature. It’s often chosen by those needing a dependable 4-slice toaster for everyday use, particularly for its ability to handle thicker breads and its straightforward controls. The auto shut-off is also a well-liked safety benefit.
- See it on Amazon here
BELLA 4 Slice Toaster with Auto Shut Off – Extra…
Add a touch of elegance to your kitchen with the BELLA 4 Slice Toaster. Beyond its beautiful matte finish and stainless steel accents, this toaster is designed for the modern family. With four spacious, extra-wide slots, it effortlessly accommodates multiple bagels, muffins, or slices of bread simultaneously. Its high-lift lever, temperature control, and auto shut-off features make it not just stylish, but also incredibly safe and easy to use, ensuring perfectly toasted items and a mess-free cleanup.
- Key Features:
- FAMILY-FRIENDLY: 4 spacious slots for various breads, muffins, and bagels.
- TOAST THE WAY YOU LIKE IT: Temperature control with 6 browning options, reheat function, and cancel button.
- CLEAN WITH EASE: High lift lever for small breads, removable crumb tray for mess-free cleanup.
- NO MORE CLUTTER: Slender profile and slick design with minimal counter space usage.
- PERFECT FOR ANY OCCASION: Elegant matte finish and stainless steel accent.
- Pros:
- Stylish design elevates kitchen decor.
- 4 slots make it efficient for families.
- High-lift lever and removable crumb tray improve user experience and cleaning.
- Safety features like auto shut-off and anti-jam are reassuring.
- Compact footprint for a 4-slice toaster.
- Cons:
- No explicit “bagel” function button (though wide slots accommodate bagels).
- 6 browning options might be less precise than others offering more.
- User Impressions: This BELLA toaster is a hit with users for its aesthetics and family-friendly capacity. Customers often highlight its ability to toast evenly and the convenience of the high-lift lever. It’s frequently recommended as a great blend of form and function, particularly for those looking for a toaster that looks good on the countertop while handling a morning rush.
- See it on Amazon here
Toaster 2 Slice Wide Slot Toaster Best Rated Prime…
Step into the future of toasting with this digital 2-slice toaster. Its standout feature is the clear LED display with a visual countdown timer, taking the guesswork out of toasting and ensuring you know exactly when your bagel will be ready. With 1.5-inch extra-wide slots, 9 adjustable browning controls, and dedicated bagel/defrost functions, this toaster offers precision and convenience that’s hard to beat, guaranteeing your bagel is toasted to your exact preference every single time.
- Key Features:
- FOUR BASIC FUNCTION: REHEAT/CANCEL/DEFROST/BAGEL to meet various toasting needs.
- Convenient Visual Digital Countdown Timer: Super clear LED display indicates remaining time.
- 1.5 Inches Extra Wide Slots: Perfectly fits bagels, muffins, waffles, Texas toast, etc.
- 9 Adjustable Browning Control Shape: Customize crispness from 1 (light) to 9 (dark).
- Removable Crumb Tray and Good Service: Easy cleanup and built-in cord storage.
- Pros:
- Digital countdown timer is a fantastic feature for precision.
- Very wide slots accommodate even the thickest bagels.
- Extensive browning control (9 levels) for fine-tuning.
- Dedicated bagel function works effectively.
- Excellent customer service mentioned.
- Cons:
- Only 2 slices, so not for larger families.
- Might be overkill if you prefer a simpler, analog toaster.
- User Impressions: Users are particularly impressed by the digital timer and the wide range of browning settings, allowing for highly personalized results. The extra-wide slots are consistently praised for handling thick items effortlessly. It’s seen as a modern, efficient choice for anyone who wants precise control over their toast and bagel perfection.
- See it on Amazon here
Elite Gourmet ECT1027B Cool Touch Toaster with 6…
The Elite Gourmet ECT1027B is your ideal compact companion, especially if you have limited counter space, live in a dorm, or enjoy RV travel. Its standout feature is the cool-touch exterior, ensuring safety even during peak operation – perfect for busy hands or small spaces. Don’t let its portable size fool you; it still offers extra-wide slots for bagels, self-centering guides for even browning, and 6 browning levels, proving that good things really do come in small packages.
- Key Features:
- NOT JUST FOR TOAST: Extra wide 1.25″ slots and 6 browning levels for bagels, waffles, specialty breads.
- COOL TOUCH: Exterior remains cool to the touch, with easy-to-use lever and non-slip feet.
- PORTABLE & LIGHTWEIGHT: Perfect for small apartments, offices, dorms, or RVs.
- SELF-CENTERING: Automatic guides ensure even heat distribution.
- CANCEL FUNCTION: Easily stop any toasting cycle.
- GREAT GIFT: Compact size, easy to use, trusted brand.
- Pros:
- Cool-touch exterior enhances safety.
- Compact and lightweight, excellent for small spaces.
- Extra-wide slots accommodate bagels despite its size.
- Self-centering guides ensure even toasting.
- Affordable and from a trusted brand.
- Cons:
- Only 2 slices.
- Lacks a dedicated “bagel” function button.
- User Impressions: Customers love this toaster for its compact design and cool-touch feature, making it a safe and convenient option for tight spaces. It’s frequently recommended for its surprising ability to toast bagels and thicker items evenly despite its small footprint. It’s a solid choice for basic, reliable toasting.
- See it on Amazon here
Oster 4 Slice Toaster, With 7 Browning Settings, Extra…
The Oster 4 Slice Toaster seamlessly blends elegant design with practical functionality, making it a stylish yet powerful addition to any kitchen. Its sleek stainless steel finish hints at the quality within, offering extra-wide slots that confidently handle everything from thin toast to hearty brioche and, of course, your favorite bagels. With convenient one-touch bagel, defrost, and cancel buttons, plus a high-lift lever, this toaster makes your morning routine effortless and delivers consistently great results.
- Key Features:
- From Toast to Brioche: Extra-wide slots hold a variety of breads, plus bagels, too.
- 3 Function Settings: One-touch bagel, defrost, and cancel buttons for added convenience.
- Easy to Use, Easy to Clean: High-lift lever elevates bread for easy retrieval, removable crumb tray.
- 7 Shade Settings: Choose your toasting shades from light to dark.
- Automatic Shut-Off: For added safety and peace of mind.
- Elevated Design: Sleek stainless steel enhances kitchen aesthetic.
- Pros:
- Attractive stainless steel design.
- Dedicated bagel function for ideal bagel toasting.
- High-lift lever and removable crumb tray for convenience.
- Automatic shut-off is a great safety feature.
- Accommodates a wide range of bread types.
- Cons:
- Some users might find the toast shades slightly inconsistent at extreme settings.
- No digital display.
- User Impressions: Users frequently commend the Oster 4-slice toaster for its sleek appearance and reliable performance, especially with bagels and thicker slices. The one-touch functions are highly appreciated for their ease of use, and the high-lift lever often gets a special mention for preventing burnt fingers. It’s a solid all-around toaster that looks good on the counter.
- See it on Amazon here
Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Toaster with Extra-Wide Slots, Bagel…
As America’s best-selling toaster brand (according to the manufacturer), the Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Toaster lives up to its reputation by prioritizing versatility and user convenience. This compact powerhouse features extra-wide slots perfect for bagels and an advanced Toast Boost function that makes retrieving smaller items a breeze. With dedicated bagel, defrost, and cancel options, and a shade selector with 7 settings, it’s designed to make your breakfast easy, enjoyable, and perfectly toasted, every single time.
- Key Features:
- EASILY TOAST ANY BREAD: Advanced features to easily toast breads, bagels, English muffins, frozen waffles, pancakes.
- EFFORTLESSLY TOAST THICKER BREADS: Extra wide slots fit Texas toast and bagels.
- AMERICA’S TOASTER BRAND: Best-selling toaster brand in the U.S.
- EASILY RETRIEVE SMALLER-SIZED BREADS: Toast Boost feature lifts smaller breads.
- KEEP COUNTERTOPS CLEANER: Slide-out crumb tray catches crumbs.
- Pros:
- Reliable performance from a trusted brand.
- Toast Boost is incredibly useful for small items.
- Dedicated bagel function ensures proper toasting.
- Extra-wide slots handle thick bagels with ease.
- Easy to clean with a slide-out crumb tray.
- Cons:
- Only 2 slices.
- Design is fairly standard.
- User Impressions: This Hamilton Beach toaster consistently receives positive feedback for its dependable performance and user-friendly features. Customers particularly love the Toast Boost and the extra-wide slots, confirming its effectiveness for bagels and other thick breads. It’s often praised as a reliable and affordable choice for everyday toasting needs.
- See it on Amazon here
FAQ Section: All Your Bagel Toaster Questions Answered
Q1: What exactly does a “bagel function” do on a toaster?
A: A bagel function is designed to toast only one side of the bagel (usually the cut side) while gently warming the crust side. This prevents the outer crust from getting over-toasted or burnt, ensuring a perfectly crispy interior and a soft exterior.
Q2: Are extra-wide slots really necessary for bagels?
A: Absolutely! Bagels are significantly thicker than standard bread slices. Extra-wide slots prevent your bagels from getting squished, allowing them to toast more evenly and preventing them from getting stuck in the toaster.
Q3: Can I toast frozen bagels in a regular toaster?
A: While you can, it’s generally not recommended without a “defrost” function. A regular toaster will often burn the outside before the inside is fully defrosted. Toasters with a defrost setting thaw the bagel first, then toast it to perfection, ensuring a much better result.
Q4: How often should I clean my toaster’s crumb tray?
A: For optimal performance and safety, it’s a good idea to empty your toaster’s crumb tray at least once a week, or more frequently if you use it daily. Built-up crumbs can cause odors, attract pests, and even pose a fire hazard.
Q5: Is a 2-slice or 4-slice toaster better for bagels?
A: This depends on your household size and how many bagels you typically toast at once. A 2-slice toaster is great for individuals or couples, while a 4-slice toaster is ideal for families or if you frequently toast multiple items simultaneously, speeding up breakfast prep.
Q6: What’s the best browning setting for bagels?
A: This is largely a matter of personal preference! If your toaster has a bagel function, start there. For general browning, a medium setting (around 3-5 out of 7-9) is usually a good starting point for a golden-brown, crispy interior without burning the crust. Adjust up or down based on your desired crispness.
Q7: Do these toasters work well with other thick breads like English muffins or artisan loaves?
A: Yes, absolutely! The features that make these toasters great for bagels – primarily the extra-wide slots and often the “defrost” and “high-lift” functions – also make them excellent for toasting English muffins, thick slices of artisan bread, waffles, and even Texas toast without issue.
Conclusion
Finding the best toasters for bagels doesn’t have to be a daunting task. With our comprehensive guide, you’re now equipped to choose a toaster that meets your specific needs, whether you prioritize digital precision, family-friendly capacity, sleek design, or ultimate budget-friendliness.
No more burnt edges or soggy middles – just perfectly toasted, golden bagels ready to be slathered with your favorite cream cheese. Invest in a quality bagel toaster, and elevate your breakfast experience every single morning. Happy toasting!
